Mindblown: a blog about philosophy.
-
( Comments for Policy of Truth ) Comment on Retributivism, Its Discontents, and Some Malcontents by Desert and Diachronic Fairness | Policy of Truth
[…] to preserve strikes me as an unwarranted commitment to a form of double jeopardy. But as I’ve already made this criticism in a previous post, I mention it now to set it […] LikeLike
-
(Policy of Truth) Desert and Diachronic Fairness
Chapter 5 of George Sher’s Desert offers an account of retributivism according to which wrongdoing generates an unfair balance of benefits and burdens that requires redress. Because this imbalance exists at a given time, but is redressed across time, Sher thinks of retributivism so conceived as exemplifying a conception of diachronic fairness, that is, of…
-
( Comments for Policy of Truth ) Comment on COVID Booster Shot Meets Health Care Monopoly by Irfan Khawaja
It’s been gratifying to see at least one left-leaning liberal get the idea that “following the FDA” is not quite the same thing as “following science” or for that matter, acting rationally: LikeLike
-
( Comments for Policy of Truth ) Comment on impartial moral anger and deserving not to be wronged by Irfan Khawaja
I think your account of impersonal moral anger needs more filling out. You identify two features: it’s not the first-personal anger of the victim, and it’s directed, impersonally, at the state of affairs of someone’s being wronged. Th…
-
( Comments for Policy of Truth ) Comment on impartial moral anger and deserving not to be wronged by Irfan Khawaja
So I’ve read this more carefully now, but I still have the same questions. (1) Just a quick question of citation: where does Sher discuss expressive views of merit? (I haven’t gotten to the chapter on merit, if that’s where it is.) (2…
-
( Comments for Policy of Truth ) Comment on Droning On by 9/11 + 20 | Policy of Truth
[…] in Palestine” and “Pedagogy Under Occupation.” (I belatedly remembered this blog post, also on pedagogical themes related to teaching 9/11-related topics, in this case, the issue of […] LikeLike
-
( Comments for Policy of Truth ) Comment on Hospitals Are Not Safe: Infection, PR, and EVS by The Lessons of 9/11: Twenty Years Later | Policy of Truth
[…] ****I highly recommend the book I’ve highlighted in the image, Michael Osterholm and Mark Olshaker’s Deadliest Enemy: Our War Against Killer Germs. Also worth reading for the larger picture is Anne Case and Angus DeatonR…
-
( Comments for Policy of Truth ) Comment on Kevin Vallier on “Cancel Culture” by The Lessons of 9/11: Twenty Years Later | Policy of Truth
[…] of the issue. If anti-war activists can’t get equal time in schools, they should feel free to cancel the shit out of the other side (within the limits of the law and of basic moral decency): denounce them, […] LikeLike
-
( Comments for Policy of Truth ) Comment on War with Iran (24): Regrets Only by The Lessons of 9/11: Twenty Years Later | Policy of Truth
[…] say so–a lot, to everyone, including your political representatives. People may well regard you as a monomaniac, but better a monomaniac than a cipher. It takes just a few monomaniacs to start a war, but it […] LikeLike
-
( Comments for Policy of Truth ) Comment on The JBMDL Afghan Account by The Lessons of 9/11: Twenty Years Later | Policy of Truth
[…] home, and in our control–the welfare of the evacuees themselves. I’ve expressed my own emotional ambivalence about that here. But morally, there’s no room for ambivalence, however one feels: we owe these evacuees, […] …
Got any book recommendations?